Is surf therapy effective?
Anyone who surfs has witnessed the end of a bad day transform into the promise of a good one within the same 24-hour span. Something about the water - flying over it, diving under it - seems to make the troubles on land feel more manageable.
Given this experience, it's natural to wonder whether surfing might provide therapeutic relief for clinical mental health conditions. Surf therapy programs are expanding rapidly, with sessions led by licensed mental health clinicians or offered as referrals from traditional therapy practices. These programs typically combine surf instruction with therapeutic techniques, serving participants in group settings over multiple weeks.
Surf therapy advocates claim benefits across demographics, suggesting these programs help with conditions including PTSD, depression, and anxiety while building trust, resilience, and overall mental wellness. But what does the research actually say about surf therapy's effectiveness? The answer is a resounding maybe, with studies supporting both sides of this question.
To understand whether surf therapy works, we need to examine how researchers approach this question. Individual studies focus on specific programs or populations, while meta-analyses gather multiple studies to identify broader patterns across the research landscape. These comprehensive reviews often provide clearer pictures by highlighting both strengths and limitations of individual studies.
The current research shows mixed results. A study examining current and former Australian Defense Force members found significant reductions in PTSD, Major Depressive Disorder, and Generalized Anxiety Disorder that persisted up to seven months after surf therapy sessions ended. For veterans and active service members facing the military's most common mental health challenges, these sustained improvements represent substantial progress.
However, other research reveals more modest outcomes. A study of children ages 8-18 found decreases in troubling symptoms during surf therapy programs, but participants returned to baseline within just six weeks after the program ended. While the immediate benefits were real, their temporary nature raises questions about long-term effectiveness.
A recent meta-analysis combined data from four studies and concluded that existing surf therapy research carries high risk for bias in both directions, making the evidence questionable either way. The authors found that current evidence doesn't establish surf therapy as effective and noted that other exercise-based interventions like hiking therapy show equal or superior results.
The meta-analysis authors emphasized that studies on surf therapy remain inadequate and require further investigation. This isn't a definitive verdict against surf therapy's effectiveness, but given the sensitivity of mental health treatment, we must be extremely careful about practices we recommend for clinical diagnoses.
The challenge lies partly in studying mental health interventions generally. Unlike measuring blood pressure or bone density, quantifying psychological well-being involves subjective assessments that vary between individuals and circumstances. Additionally, surf therapy combines multiple elements - physical activity, ocean environment, social interaction, and therapeutic guidance - making it difficult to isolate which components drive any observed benefits.
None of this diminishes individual experiences with surfing's mental health benefits. Even if future studies show that formalized programs don't work on average, everyone responds differently to various interventions. Some find relief through surfing while others benefit more from different approaches.
If surfing genuinely helps your mental health, that experience remains valid regardless of what population-level studies might conclude. Get out there.
Further Reading: